logo

45 pages 1 hour read

A Long Petal of the Sea

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2019

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 3, Chapters 9-13Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 3: “Returns and Roots”

Chapter 9 Summary: “1948-1970”

The Dalmaus are renting a beach cabin in the Chilean summer of February, though Victor stays at home to work during the week. The poet Neruda is in trouble, “accused of slander and calumny by the government” (192). Victor agrees to hide Neruda at his home while his family is away. For two weeks, the poet and his wife stay with Victor. The isolation is maddening for Neruda. Ushered away at night, Neruda will next see Victor 13 months later, when he flees Chile via the Andes to Argentina. Victor escorts him on horseback to the border.

On Marcel’s 10th birthday, a letter arrives from Carme, who is alive. Victor, Roser, and Marcel travel to Andorra to meet her. Carme meets them at the bus station, where Victor is reduced to tears and the women kiss one another. Marcel is fascinated with Carme’s wrinkles and aged body. Carme expected to die the night she left Roser and Aitor, as she fell asleep in the cold. When she woke, she realized that Roser and Guillem’s child was alive, and that gave her reason to live. A stray puppy came over to her and snuggled with her for warmth. That puppy saved her life, as a peasant couple heard it whining and went to investigate. Taken in by the couple, Carme helped them work the land and ultimately traveled with them to Andorra, a place known for “smuggling anything […] between Spain and France, including people” (200) during and after World War II.

It took years for Carme to track down Elisabeth Eidenbenz and then the Quaker couple who had sheltered Roser for information about her family. The couple had an envelope with Felipe’s address in Chile, which ultimately led to the reunification of the Dalmaus. Taking a year to decide to emigrate, Carme eventually joins the family in Chile. She brings with her the very dog that saved her life so long ago. Once in Chile, Carme and Jordi Malone develop a relationship, with Carme “devoting herself entirely to looking after” (214) Jordi in his old age.

Traveling often to Venezuela to perform in the antique orchestra, Roser encounters Aitor. They begin an affair that will last seven years and be “intense in emotion and relaxed in expression” (210). Both are married and have no intention of breaking those marriages up. The affair is clandestine and ends when a stroke leaves Aitor a hemiplegic, needing the care of his wife. Victor knows Roser is having an affair and finds himself missing her. He realizes how much he loves her; she is “the anchor of his existence” (206). Victor and Roser made love after his failed relationship with Ofelia and have since slept together in the same bed. Victor does not learn that the affair was with Aitor until years later.

In September 1970, Salvador Allende wins the presidency to an outpouring of celebration on the streets. The socialist revolution begins. Carme fears this will end as it did in Spain in the 1930s. Immediately, there are conservative plans to stop Allende, with the army commander-in-chief soon assassinated. Congress ratifies Allende, however, and he becomes “the first democratically elected Marxist head of state” (217). In the United States, there is fear that such elections “might spread like wildfire through the rest of America and Europe” (218).

Chapter 10 Summary: “1970-1973”

With Allende’s government in place, the country experiences shortages of essential products like baby formula, toilet paper, and food, due to the “opposition’s cunning sabotage” (221). The working classes are “still euphoric,” but the country is divided into “irreconcilable groups” (223), with elites temporarily fleeing to neighboring countries. The del Solars head to Buenos Aires and leave Juana to manage the house in Santiago. Felipe is the only family member to stay behind, but he too has become a conservative.

By now, Marcel is an adult. When the mining industry is nationalized, a copper corporation gives him a grant to study geology in the United States. In Colorado, Marcel is “comfortable in his own skin” (228) and moves into an apartment with “his first love, a young Jamaican woman” (228). Marcel is therefore absent from Chile when Carme dies on her 87th birthday. When Jordi awakes to find her dead, he wanders off. Later, his body is found in the river. The couple were together for 19 years. Marcel, who had the closest relationship with Carme, is inconsolable. Buying a plot in the cemetery to bury Carme and Jordi, Victor realizes “from this moment on he belonged definitively to Chile” (231). His dead are buried here.

After warning Allende that the right wing is gathering arms, Victor finds that the president is already aware of the situation but cannot legally act to raid factories. Amid this tension, homage is paid to Pablo Neruda, who received the Nobel Prize the previous year, at the National Stadium. Neruda is ill and “afraid for Chile” (233). As it turns out, he is correct to be afraid. On September 11, 1973, there is a military coup in Chile, with General Augusto Pinochet leading it and personifying the dictatorship. Allende is killed along with many others.

Both Roser and Marcel are out of the country at the time of the coup. Victor is working tirelessly at the hospital. When he emerges from work after nine days, he observes an “unrecognizable city” (236), with revolutionary murals gone and shop windows filled with products previously unavailable and now at soaring prices. The del Solars return to Chile, “ready to reclaim their privileges and the reins of the economy, though not political power” (239). Pablo Neruda dies, and there is suspicion that he was poisoned. While protest is allowed at his funeral, given the international attention it receives, the government takes photos of those attending.

Victor is arrested after being denounced by his neighbor, whom Victor had treated well. He becomes one of the many who disappear. In his case, he is taken to a concentration camp in the north, where he is forced to strip and stand in the “hot desert sun for hours without food or water” (242). About to turn 60, Victor finds himself in a camp even worse than the one in France. Roser returns to Chile and spends months searching for him.

Chapter 11 Summary: “1974-1983”

For 11 months, Victor endures horrendous conditions and abuse in a concentration camp. Starved, sunburned, beaten, and humiliated, Victor finds inner strength. He says little at the camp and knows that Roser is searching for him. His bad fortune changes when the camp’s commandant suffers a heart attack and Victor saves him, performing the necessary surgery at a provincial hospital. Soon after that, Victor is paroled. He and Roser profess their love for one another over tears when reunited.

Given the repressive conditions under the Pinochet regime, Victor fears being arrested again. He seeks asylum in the Venezuelan embassy and is soon given safe passage to Venezuela. Once again, Victor and Roser are in a new country, though Roser has spent much time in Venezuela with the orchestra. She is more accepting of the easy-going culture where “any excuse was good enough to celebrate with music, dancing, and alcohol” (254). Victor finds the adjustment more difficult but is able to get work in “Caracus’s oldest hospital” (254). Visiting Aitor, Roser finds him happy despite his confinement to a wheelchair. He confesses that he is “a better husband, father, and grandfather” (251) in the wheelchair than when he could walk. Roser finally tells Victor about her past affair with Aitor. While that confession “awoke in him retrospective jealousy” (253), he sees the uselessness of worrying about the past and delights in his love of Roser.

After a long illness, Franco dies on November 20, 1975. The following year, Victor and Roser return to Spain for the first time since their flight as refugees. The country is unrecognizable to them: “Forty years of Francoism had left a deep imprint noticeable in the way people related to one another, and in every aspect of culture” (257). After six months, Victor and Roser conclude that this is not their home. They are Chilean, but for now, they return to Venezuela.

In Venezuela, Victor and Roser attend an exhibit of Ofelia del Solar’s art. It is the first time that Victor has seen Ofelia since their affair of so many years ago. It took “several seconds” (261) for Ofelia to remember Victor’s name, leaving Victor to conclude that “what for him had been a stab to the heart had left no trace in her” (261). Making excuses, Roser leaves Victor and Ofelia. Over a drink, Ofelia tells Victor of her deep love for Matias, who died of a heart attack six years ago. She has two adult children and enjoys her artwork. In providing an update about her family, Ofelia speaks of Father Urbina “with sarcasm” (264), noting the priest’s defense of the dictatorship’s methods. Victor is not impressed with Ofelia’s artwork or character. When he returns home to Roser, she bursts out laughing. She knew he would be disappointed with Ofelia and would return to her.

Chapter 12 Summary: “1983-1991”

After nine years, word arrives that Victor is among those exiles authorized to return to Chile. Marcel goes first to “scout out the terrain” and reports that Chile is prosperous on the surface, but the “degree of inequality” is “staggering” (268). When Marcel accepts a job at a copper corporation there, Roser and Victor decide to return. At first, Victor, as a former dissident, is not allowed to work in the public hospital. Instead, he finds work in Santiago’s “most exclusive clinic” (270). The military government had privatized health care, treating it as a consumer good. Felipe, who lives in England now, visits Victor there on one of his frequent trips to Chile. The two old friends now have diametrically opposed ideologies, with Felipe a conservative and Victor a progressive.

In addition to his paid job, Victor volunteers in one of the many shantytowns in Santiago. His patients there live “in shacks made of cardboard and wooden planks with beaten earth floors,” and they have “no running water, electricity, or latrines” (272). Victor spends his salary buying medical supplies for these clients, leaving him and Roser to rely on her earnings and their savings. Thanks to Venezuelan generosity from ambassador Valentin Sanchez, Roser performs at open-air concerts and works to form a youth orchestra. Roser also accompanies Victor to the shantytown and teaches music. After three years volunteering in this community, Victor and Roser arrive one day to find only “bulldozers clearing the ground where the shanties had been” (277). The police and soldiers came during the night to evacuate the residents at gunpoint, ensuring the poor stay invisible.

Finally, in 1987, the dictatorship begins to relax some restrictions, and a referendum is held in 1988 to decide if Pinochet will remain in power for eight more years. The people vote no in droves. With no US or military backing, Pinochet leaves office in March 1990. After 17 years, Chile makes a slow return to democracy. With Pinochet gone, Victor is welcomed back to the public hospital and becomes a celebrity of sorts, “the most admired [cardiac] specialist in the country” (280). Roser is surprised with Victor’s reaction, one of vanity which is uncharacteristic of him.

At 73, Roser is diagnosed with terminal cancer. This devastating news brings Victor crashing back to earth, and he takes time off to be with Roser. Six years ago, the couple had purchased a home in a part of Santiago that was still bucolic. There, they enjoy the peace and beauty of nature. Marcel visits regularly. Roser accepts her impending death stoically, but it takes Victor time to give up. Finally, he does, saying, “I’m not going to let you suffer anymore” (286).

Chapter 13 Summary: “1994”

Three years after Roser’s death, Victor plans to spend his 80th birthday alone. He prepares a special Catalonian meal, allowing the “legendary aroma” to invade “the house and his soul” (292). Marcel calls and encourages him to invite his neighbor, Meche, over for dinner. Both Roser in her final days and now Marcel encourage Victor to form a relationship with Meche, whom they see as “an ideal partner” (294). Victor declines to do so, as he remembers his previous loves. Of course, the “only woman who counted was Roser” (291). He is content to be alone with his animals in the house that he and Roser shared.

Just as he is relaxing before dinner, a visitor arrives claiming to be his daughter. It took Ingrid Schnake a long time to track Victor down, as she is now 52 years old and about to become a grandmother herself. For the first time, Victor learns about Ofelia’s first pregnancy. When Ofelia insisted on keeping the baby, Father Urbina conspired to take the baby from Ofelia without her knowledge. Only Laura and the midwife knew of the plan and participated in it. They all lied to Ofelia, telling her that she had a baby boy who died. The baby was adopted by a loving German couple who lived in the south of the country.

This lie haunted Laura, who on her deathbed asked Juana to find the baby and let the truth come out. Juana took this promise seriously, as she saw its fulfillment necessary for Laura to enter heaven. Enlisting Felipe in her task, they first went to Father Urbana, who readily admitted the deed and defended his actions. He could not remember the name of the couple but let slip that money was donated. After much effort, Felipe found the record of the donation, and he then told Ofelia what happened. Although Ofelia was not interested in meeting her long-lost daughter, she traveled with Felipe and Juana to meet her. Ingrid resembled a younger Ofelia, but the two did not bond. Ofelia finally named Victor as Ingrid’s father. With this promise of finding the baby complete, Juana was ready to die and did so soon thereafter. Felipe, who was so close to her, buried her in the family plot.

Victor is ecstatic to learn that he has a daughter and three grandchildren, and he phones Marcel to tell him the good news. He in no way takes the place of Ingrid’s real father who raised her, but he will be part of her life moving forward. They spend the night of his birthday sharing a Catalonian meal and talking. While they do not resemble one another physically, they share traits, particularly a tendency toward depression. She encourages Victor to not retire from life but to seek adventure and maybe fall in love once more. After Ingrid leaves, Victor resolves to share some of his home-cooked meal and dessert with his neighbor Meche.

Part 3, Chapters 9-13 Analysis

Allende depicts the strength of familial love in this section, beginning with the character of Carme. Under unbearable conditions, given her age in the retreat from Franco’s forces, Carme decides to fight for her life because of her grandchild. She knows that Roser is carrying her grandchild and this gives her reason to live. Later relentless in searching for her family, she eventually finds them and moves to be closer to them. Ultimately, family is home. When Carme dies, this sense of belonging to Chile is reinforced because family is now buried there.

With the wisdom of experience, Carme worries that the nightmare of the Spanish Civil War is about to play out in Chile. Elected president in 1970, Salvadore Allende sought to restructure the economy on socialist lines but is committed to democracy. He aimed to spread the wealth from the upper classes to all Chileans. The United States and other capitalist countries viewed his election as a threat to their economic interests. The US, under President Nixon, authorized the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) to engage in a covert operation to prevent Allende from taking office. While this operation was unsuccessful, the US-led international reaction against Chile’s economic policies had disastrous effects on the nation’s economy. An atmosphere of inflation, food shortages, and labor strikes helped set the stage for the military coup.

Once in power, Pinochet’s regime was ruthless. The author uses Victor’s experience of arrest and torture in the camps to tell this history. While there is disagreement on exact numbers, there is a memorial to 3,200 people who were killed or disappeared under Pinochet’s regime. Officially, 1,100 are registered as disappeared. Torture, in the forms of electrocution, waterboarding, food deprivation, and confinement to tiny areas, was commonplace, with estimates ranging from 27,000 to 38,000 victims. Like Victor, more than 200,000 Chileans went into exile during this period.

Victor’s second experience with torture and exile is especially trying given his older age. He finds it difficult to adjust to life in Venezuela. He and Roser have made their life in Chile, and that is where they belong. This Chilean identity becomes clear to both characters when they return to Spain after Franco’s death. It is no longer where they belong. However, they cannot yet return to their home and must remain exiles in Venezuela.

Through Ofelia and Victor’s biological daughter Ingrid, the author emphasizes the necessity of love and connection to the human condition. Roser accepted her death before Victor and encouraged him to marry again. When Ingrid visits, it seems to Victor that he is hearing Roser’s words that humans need connection with others as well as hope. In deciding to go to Meche’s house, Victor chooses to keep living. This decision in no way detracts from his love for his deceased wife. As the interaction with Ingrid shows, love is not exclusive or limited. Ingrid will always love her adoptive parents, but there’s room in her heart and her life for Victor too. Likewise, when Victor tells Marcel of his daughter, Marcel’s reaction is not jealous but joyous. Familial love is enduring and unlimited.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 45 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools