43 pages • 1 hour read
For the first time, Dre speaks. He and Celestial have moved in together—they live in the house Celestial grew up in, the house she shared with Roy during their marriage, the house next door to Dre’s childhood home. Dre recounts how he could not remember a time he did not love Celestial. “My affection for her is etched onto my body like the Milky Way birthmark scoring my shoulder blades” (95). Growing up, they had a closeness, like brother and sister (when Dre’s parents divorced, Celestial’s father assumed the role of Dre’s surrogate father). That closeness, Dre admits, had never translated into serious dating. After Celestial returned from Washington and matriculated at Morehouse, Dre introduced her to Roy, a frat brother. He knew immediately there was a spark: “They were good together” (102). Now, with Roy imprisoned, he is determined to make Celestial his wife, to make their relationship “legit, aboveboard” (108). It is not easy for him. Pursuing Celestial, for Dre, is like courting a widow, an emotionally vulnerable woman haunted by ghosts, uncertain over any new commitments.
Now, the day before Thanksgiving, Celestial shares with Dre the news of Roy’s early release. Dre planned to ask Celestial to marry him during her family’s holiday meal even though Celestial was legally still married to Roy. That night the two make love, and Dre spontaneously asks Celestial to marry him. She agrees and takes his ring.
The next day at dinner, Dre is uneasy over how to announce their engagement. The “pleasant racket” (118) of the dinner talk centers, of course, on Roy’s imminent release. Impulsively, after dinner, Dre pushes back from the table, stands “like a lighthouse” (120), and simply makes the announcement. The father bitterly objects: “Roy is a hostage of the state. He is a victim of America. The least you could do is unhand his wife when he gets back” (121). Celestial’s mother is not so sure, trusting her daughter to know her own mind.
The week before Christmas, Roy walks out of prison. His biological father offered “1,001 life lessons for the unincarcerated” (124). He cautions him that, after five years, life had moved on for those waiting for him: “Your woman has been in the world this whole time” (124). Big Roy alone meets him. During the drive back to Eloe, the father mentions Olive’s death. Roy cannot bring himself to tell his father of his friendship with his biological father. At dinner the father asks about Celestial. He states, “She didn’t divorce me” (129). He is haunted by her letter saying she could no longer be his wife—the rest of her letters he wadded up and flushed down his cell’s metal commode years earlier.
Now, Celestial speaks, but Roy chimes in, the two sharing the story of their first date. It was, she recalls, a vintage meet-cute. She was a fledgling artist, a doll maker just out of college with a BA in folk art and textiles. She struggled to find her niche and start her business, “Babydolls,” in the hip art scene in New York City; Roy was in town as part of a sales conference for his textbook company. These two lost souls far from home run into each other at a party. Initially Celestial is wary—she recognizes a cad when she sees one. Unable to find a taxi, Roy walks Celestial to her place—only to stumble on a burglar just leaving her apartment complex. Roy gives chase and confronts the burglar, but is kicked hard in the face, loosening a tooth. Although he does not get her belongings back, he becomes Celestial’s “hero” (145)—rather than seeking any immediate medical help or even the police, the two go to her tiny studio apartment where Celestial tends lovingly to his injuries. The delay costs him the tooth, but, as we learn much later, Celestial keeps the tooth in a small felt box in her jewelry case.
The opening monologues of Book Two establish a keen feeling of displacement and anxiety over things being not quite right despite the appearance of rightness. On the surface, two events are chronicled that should be cause for celebration: Roy is freed from prison and Dre and Celestial announce their engagement. Neither of these events are as joyful as they should be.
The narrative of Roy’s return to the world from his long imprisonment is keyed to Psalm 23, the magnificent song of reassurance to a troubled and doubtful David that, despite being besieged on every side by difficulties and unexpected woes, God will direct his life, and all will work out. The second book takes for its title one of the psalm’s most consoling passages, how the caring God will prepare a splendid table for David in the very midst of his enemies. Amid chaos and uncertainty, the psalm advises, trust in God to direct the way out to peace. Here, we are given a series of dinners, a variety of tables spread with plenty.
Thus, the title of the section reassures us that things will work out—the problem is how. The way out is radically different for each of the three characters in the love triangle. For the first time, we hear Dre. His narrative hardly makes him out as a cartoonish interloper or opportunist. Nor, when she speaks, does Celestial come across as cold, calculating, or driven by selfishness or ego. Roy’s release from prison narrative is defined by his modesty, his apparent lack of anger, and his driving need for a return to normalcy. The problem, then, is that each of the three lovers is paradoxically, both selfish and selfless, heroic and villainous, giving and taking. The impending tragedy is no one’s fault, which is a realistic yet unsatisfying narrative of events.
The Davenport Thanksgiving dinner raises critical questions about the definition of family and the importance of home. There are few more striking tableaux that celebrate the American family than the Thanksgiving table. The table here groans with an abundance of plenty. The scene directly alludes to the Psalm’s reference the splendid table set amidst the enemy. Roy, of course, is not there. The announcement of Celestial’s engagement upends the holiday and shatters the family dynamic. Without Roy, this dinner both is and is not family, is and is not home. We cannot help but compare Roy’s departure from prison. He comes out alone and is greeted only by his father. Roy wonders whether anyone who knew him before prison would even recognize him now. Like David, he is beset with anxieties, troubled and uncertain. The absence of a mother figure is palpable as the adoptive father and son share a modest holiday dinner of baked chicken, green beans, and microwaved mac and cheese. “Thank you,” Big Roy prays, his head bowed, “thank you for this homecoming” (132).
We have then two tables set, two entirely different concepts of Thanksgiving and familial bonds. When Dre stuns Celestial’s family by announcing their engagement, Celestial’s father and mother are decidedly divided over an appropriate reaction. As the father angrily says, “I’ll tell you what Roy is going to see: he is going to see a wife who wouldn’t keep her legs closed and a so-called friend who doesn’t know what it means to be a man, let alone a black man” (121). For Roy and his father, the two cannot eat, overwhelmed by emotion. The food cools down until it is tough and dry. The two cannot console each other, no gesture seems sufficient.
We are struck by the sense that these two dinners now set into place the need for Roy to find his way home, whatever that now means, and for Celestial to define her heart, whatever that now means.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features: