61 pages • 2 hours read
Kabir is upset that Appa didn’t tell ajji and ajja about him and Amma earlier, but they reiterate that they used to be more hateful and less accepting of people than they are now. They’re pleased that Amma picked a name for Kabir that honors both the Hindu and Muslim parts of his heritage.
Kabir is pleased not to have guards watching him or to have to ask permission for everything, such as to drink water or use the restroom at night. Ajji and ajja tell Kabir this is his home, but he still doesn’t feel completely at home without Amma.
Kabir eats breakfast with Patti (his grandmother), and then they go shopping for school clothes. She buys him several sets, and when he says he doesn’t need so many, she says it’s good to have more than what’s needed. They also buy a set of clothes for Rani, and Patti lets Kabir use her smartphone to call Rani. He tells her that his father is dead but he’s doing well. She loves the school so far because she sleeps in a tent, eats good food, has lessons outside, and has made friends.
Kabir and Amma exchange letters, but she doesn’t say anything about Appa’s death. Amma encourages Kabir not to worry about her and to enjoy his freedom. He can’t bring himself to give up on her.
Kabir’s father’s cousin, Salma Aunty, visits with her son, Junaid, who’s around Kabir’s age. The boys go outside to play, and Junaid asks Kabir about his past. Junaid then says Kabir’s mom probably did something awful to get put in prison. Kabir ignores him. Junaid speaks to some other boys playing cricket. Kabir goes back upstairs, saying he doesn’t want to play with Junaid anymore because of what he said. He already has friends, Rani and Malli, so he doesn’t need Junaid.
Patti and Thatha tell Kabir they believe him about his mom being a good person and possibly even innocent. However, they don’t have money to hire a lawyer. Patti promises to speak to Junaid’s mother about what he said. She says that maybe they can be friends one day, but Kabir’s not sure about this.
Kabir accompanies Patti to the market to shop for dinner. They return to the building, and Kabir helps her bring the groceries in, passing the boys playing cricket once again. Patti encourages him to play with the boys, but Kabir would rather help cook today. His father also used to like to help cook, Patti says, and was brave in trying new things and remaining true to himself.
They eat lunch, and then Patti and Thatha take a nap. Patti lets Kabir use her phone and says it has games on it. He researches lawyers in the area and then starts calling them, explaining that his mother is in prison and innocent, that he can’t pay, but that he needs help. Most hang up on him, but he remembers what Patti told him. She described what his father said about being brave: “Fear is a lock. Courage is a key” (229). This gives him the resolve to keep trying. Patti and Thatha wake up before he has any success. Patti then tells him she can see the calls he made (he didn’t realize this because he doesn’t have much experience using smartphones). She agrees to let him keep trying a bit each day but warns him not to get too hopeful and also asks him to play cricket outside with the boys so that he doesn’t spend all his time worrying about something that’s ultimately not within his complete control.
The following day, while Patti and Kabir are returning from grocery shopping, a cricket ball flies at Kabir. He catches it, and the boys playing are impressed. They ask Kabir to join their game, and Patti encourages this. One boy, named Lakshman, is very friendly toward Kabir, asking many questions. Kabir confesses that he doesn’t know how to play cricket but he’s a fast learner. Lakshman says Kabir can be the fielder, whose role is simple, but later he’ll teach Kabir the full rules. Kabir has a good time playing.
Afterward, he walks back upstairs with Lakshman, who continues asking questions and learns that Kabir’s father is dead and his mother is in prison for a crime she didn’t commit. Lakshman, who (like Kabir) is from Chennai, is impressed by Kabir’s mission to find a lawyer. He thinks maybe one day he’ll become a lawyer who helps those who can’t afford one. Kabir tells Lakshman he has good ideas, and Lakshman thanks him; Kabir likes it when people say “thank you.” Kabir says maybe Viji Aunty can help him and Amma. Lakshman agrees and offers to accompany him there the following day.
In the morning, before Patti and Thatha wake up, Kabir and Lakshman take the bus to Viji Aunty’s school. A large wall surrounds it, but the guard is nice and opens the gate for the boys. They spot Rani, who seems happier than ever. She shows them her tent and some other kids’ tents. However, she now realizes that being inside isn’t all bad. In fact, she’s considering moving inside, where most kids already live, when the rainy season arrives. Kabir says his grandparents are wonderful, but he still wants to free Amma, which he was hoping Viji Aunty could help with. Rani takes the boys to her.
Viji Aunty has both boys call their grandparents or parents to explain where they are and then tells them that next time they must bring the adults with them. She listens to Kabir’s story and tells him that her sister-in-law, Tanvi, works at a law firm that assists people without much money. They call her. Immediately, Tanvi Ma’am reveals that, even if Amma were guilty, the sentence for aggravated theft is only seven years. Kabir wants them to prove Amma’s innocence, but Tanvi says they can’t prove that a decade after the alleged crime with no evidence, but they can probably get her out given that the maximum sentence for the crime she was accused of has already passed. Kabir expresses his gratitude to Viji Aunty.
Every afternoon, Kabir accompanies Patti to the market, then helps her carry groceries upstairs, and then plays cricket with Lakshman and the other boys. Thatha watches them from the window upstairs. Tanvi Ma’am calls weekly to discuss Amma’s case. While looking into it, they found other problems with the prison, and the superintendent has been fired. More women besides Amma will be freed, and they’ll try to improve the conditions for those remaining in the prison. Patti and Thatha help Kabir adjust to life outside prison, which can be scary because it’s so new, even though it’s preferable to prison. Prayer, meals, market trips, and other routines help Kabir adjust.
Kabir is playing cricket one day and sees Thatha watching him from right there, not from upstairs. Thatha asks to speak to Kabir, and they go upstairs to Patti. They tell Kabir that tomorrow, they’ll travel to Chennai to pick up Amma upon her release from prison and bring her home to live with them. Kabir is overjoyed and calls Rani to tell her the great news. She commends him for his efforts, and he thanks her for her friendship, which helped make it possible to realize his goals.
Kabir, Patti, and Thatha travel to Chennai, and then Tanvi Ma’am picks them up and drives them to the prison. Amma comes out, and Grandma Knife also comes to say hi. The moment when Kabir hugs Amma, with no one telling him to stop, is the best of his life. Kabir promises to become a lawyer one day and free Grandma Knife, but she says it’s enough for her to know Amma and Kabir are free.
Seeing Amma with Patti and Thatha, Kabir knows he’s the missing “puzzle piece” that will hold his family together. He’s sad that his father can’t be there too, but he’s happy his family and friend circle is now bigger than he ever imagined.
Kabir encounters more trustworthy adults in this section, which contributes thematically to The Importance of Family and Friendship as well as Resilience and Positivity as Tools for Change. Although Fake Uncle, who claimed to be family but was really an enemy, tried to trick Kabir, he learns through Patti and Thatha that his family really can get bigger than he ever imagined and reinforce that some adults really do want to help him. Although Patti and Thatha are humans, not superheroes, and can’t magically free Amma from prison or afford a lawyer, they’re part of the team that, together, frees Amma. For example, they allow Kabir to use their phones to call lawyers, and provide support and guidance for him in this effort. Although these lawyers aren’t the ones that free Amma, this is part of the trial-and-error process that leads to Kabir’s eventual success.
With no luck calling random lawyers on the phone, Kabir switches his strategy and goes to visit Viji Aunty, who he knows from past experience is a helpful person even though she’s not a lawyer. Like the police officer who connected the kids to Viji Aunty when they needed a home, Viji Aunty in turn connects Kabir with her sister-in-law, Tanvi Ma’am, who works for a law firm that helps people who can’t afford lawyers. This shows how friendship, family, and community can work as a web. Connections don’t end with one person but continue branching out through referrals.
The ease with which Tanvi Ma’am identifies the problems with Amma’s case and helps free her from prison reveals the gross incompetence of others working in the prison system. Even if the prison employees didn’t care about doing the right thing, keeping people imprisoned after their sentences are up wastes money and resources. They simply didn’t notice or care how long Amma had been there (just like it took three years for anyone to notice that Kabir had already turned six). Looking into Amma’s case, Tanvi Ma’am and her colleagues uncover similar cases, and other people besides Amma are being released too. However, Tanvi Ma’am’s influence is still limited because of her own social position: Like Patti and Thatha, she’s not a superhero and has limited funds and resources. She can’t free everyone or fix everything, and it’s unclear whether firing the superintendent will do any good. When the previous warden was fired, someone equally dangerous and ineffective was assigned. However, the existence of people like Tanvi Ma’am, who seek to do good (like Amma wants Kabir to do), make the world a better place. This is another reason to be good that Kabir learns: If everyone is bad, the world stops working well.
To survive outside prison and free Amma, Kabir must be resilient, courageous, persistent, strong, loving, and loyal. However, no matter how well he channels these qualities, he can’t free Amma without teamwork, help from friends, family, and other good citizens. She’s in a prison that’s guarded by people with advanced weapons. A nine-year-old could never break her out and then evade the people trying to catch her. Also, this wouldn’t be the “right” thing to do. Although the novel clearly suggests a difference between what’s legally right and what’s morally right, sometimes they do align, as in this case, when the best way to get Amma out is to seek legal help from the right lawyer, one who gets paid by someone other than the clients and one who prioritizes what’s morally right in applying the law. Additionally, as Rani points out, it was not Tanvi Ma’am alone who saved Amma. It took a combination of good people doing the right thing at different times, connected by a web of good intentions: Tanvi Ma’am, Patti and Thatha, Kabir, Rani, Viji Aunty, the cook at Fake Uncle’s employer’s house, the woman who lost her earring, and certain police officers. This helps Kabir understand how he fits into the puzzle of the world. He’s not the only piece and can’t face every challenge alone no matter how much courage he musters. However, with family, friendship, and teamwork, the possibilities expand significantly.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Padma Venkatraman
Action & Adventure Reads (Middle Grade)
View Collection
Asian American & Pacific Islander...
View Collection
Books that Teach Empathy
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Community
View Collection
Contemporary Books on Social Justice
View Collection
Family
View Collection
Friendship
View Collection
Indian Literature
View Collection
Juvenile Literature
View Collection
Nation & Nationalism
View Collection
Politics & Government
View Collection
Poverty & Homelessness
View Collection
Realistic Fiction (Middle Grade)
View Collection
School Book List Titles
View Collection
The Journey
View Collection
Valentine's Day Reads: The Theme of Love
View Collection