105 pages • 3 hours read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.
Summary
Background
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
The group of humans is now in the training room, which appears as a vast tropical forest. The sky looks like the Earth sky and there is a wide river, and huge trees everywhere. There are abundant flora, insects, and small animals.
Nikanj tells Lilith that they will be given tools later, but for now, they are to get used to the place and settle in more firmly with their ooloi. Lilith warns Nikanj that some of the group will build boats and try to escape because they believe they are on Earth. Nikanj replies that anyone who tries to leave will find the walls of the room and return. The only way out is to learn to be self-sufficient in this environment so they can be returned to Earth. Lilith thinks that Nikanj must know that the humans will try to run once back on Earth, though it talks about mixed settlements of humans and Oankali, with genetically mixed children.
Lilith avoids going back to the others for the moment. Most of the group are tolerating each other and are bonded to their ooloi, though Curt and Gabriel remain highly drugged. In a way, Lilith admires their ability to resist the conditioning. She asks Nikanj what they will do with people who cannot adapt to live with the Oankali. Nikanj replies that if they are not violent, the men will be returned to Earth also since there are so few humans.
Nikanj says that some Oankali favored waiting to bond with the humans until they came to the training floor since the conditions would make it easier to become a cohesive unit, a family. Nikanj continues that most of the Oankali could not wait that long to bond: “It might be better for both our peoples if we were not so strongly drawn to you” (202).
Tools are passed out to the group, including things that could be used as weapons, such as axes and machetes. Lilith speaks privately to the people who continue to be a problem, such as Curt, telling him that she chose to Awaken him because he was the kind of person needed down on Earth: “I want you to live to get down there. Don’t go Peter’s way, Curt” (202). The way he stares at her frightens Lilith and she asks Nikanj to put Curt back to sleep. Nikanj replies that Curt’s ooloi, Yahjahyi, thinks that Curt will be all right. Lilith asks Nikanj what Peter’s ooloi had thought of Peter. Nikanj says that Tehjaht had never told the other ooloi what it thought of Peter’s state of mind, so they had not realized there was a problem.
Lilith still does not believe that Curt can be trusted. Nikanj replies that Yahjahyi is ready for any trouble and that Celene will help as well since she does not want to lose Curt. Curt’s natural tendency to protect the vulnerable will not allow him to risk himself.
Gabriel tells Lilith that he does not believe Curt will be all right. Gabriel is no longer drugged and can speak freely. He thinks that Curt views the ooloi sexual act as akin to rape, even if the sex that goes on is confined to his mind. Gabriel says that does not matter and that Curt will not let the assault continue.
Lilith asks Gabriel how he has made his peace with sex with his ooloi and he replies, “Who says I have?” (203). Lilith is frightened and says they cannot lose Gabriel, too. He says he will not do anything drastic until he finds out for himself what is going on, as he still does not believe that they are not on Earth. Lilith says that Kahguyaht could show Gabriel things that would convince him, that might even convince Curt; Gabriel says that nothing will convince Curt. Gabriel maintains that Curt will eventually attack his ooloi as Peter did, only more effectively.
Lilith teaches the group how to build a roofed cabin like the one Lilith and the ooloi had built previously. The group learns how to cut tropical fruit from the tree, how to dig roots, and begins planting crops.
Two men and a woman take the tools they were given and run away into the forest. The Oankali decide not to follow them. Nikanj tells Joseph and Lilith that the escaped people are being watched by the ship, so if they are hurt, they will be tended to.
More humans leave the settlement, and their ooloi look like Tehjaht had when Peter died, still and silent, their tentacles clenched like lumps. Their mates come into the forest to take them away. Watching a man and woman tend to their ooloi mate, Lilith wonders how many other people might leave, and what they would do out in the forest. She even begins to doubt briefly that this is a ship, not Earth, and that perhaps they really could row away in a boat to freedom. Lilith does not truly believe this, but the doubt persists: “The thought would not let her alone no matter what facts she felt she knew. What if the others were right?” (207).
That evening, Tate tells Lilith that Curt and Celene are gone. They are both surprised that Curt didn’t harm an Oankali before he left. Tate then tells Lilith that she and Gabriel are leaving too, that night, along with some others. Tate says, “Listen, I’m not just telling you for the hell of it. We want you to go with us” (208). Lilith brings Tate away from the center of the camp, where they can’t be heard by the other humans; Tate continues to tell her that Gabriel has already asked Joseph to go, and he has agreed.
Lilith maintains that they are on an island, on a ship, and she believes that they will come to walls if they run away; “All because the Oankali said so,” Tate says (209). Lilith says her beliefs are based on what she saw and felt, but Tate says that was what the Oankali made her see and feel. Lilith says that Nikanj was too young to manipulate what she felt and saw. Tate starts to say awkwardly that Lilith and Nikanj are close, but ends up not going anywhere with her comment. Tate says that she had told Gabriel that she would get Lilith to promise not to tell the Oankali that they are leaving. Lilith wants to know if Tate thinks that she would; Tate finally says, “I’m beginning not to care what you do” (210).
Lilith walks away and Tate runs after her, apologizing, and asks Lilith again if she will leave with them. Lilith says that she and Joseph will meet them at a point on the riverbank after breakfast. Lilith returns to the camp, wondering how many of the Oankali have heard their conversation. She figures that Nikanj would know she planned to leave, and would send for its mates. She wonders why the other ooloi had not sent for their mates, since they must have known in advance that their bonded humans were leaving. Lilith considers that this must be a kind of test to prove that they have learned how to live in this environment.
Joseph comes up to Lilith and asks if she’s spoken to Tate. Lilith says she has, and that she needs to talk to him. Joseph tells her that he wants to go, making Lilith ask if he would truly leave her. Joseph asks why Lilith would stay, and if it is to be with Nikanj. Lilith replies that there is nowhere to run, but Joseph says that he needs to see for himself.
Joseph begs Lilith to come with him, to not make him leave her. Softly, Lilith agrees to go along.
The Oankali plan to repopulate the Earth has progressed to the training floor stage in these chapters. Many of the group, even Lilith’s friends and supporters like Tate, are having a harder time accepting that the forest is part of the ship rather than actually on the Earth. The old-growth trees, the river, the moon and stars in the sky, all seem far too real and Earth-like to be some artificial place that the Oankali constructed on their ship.
In these chapters, Lilith fears for the success of the Oankali plans. She worriedly tells Nikanj that she’s afraid that people will build boats and run away, but it tells her not to worry about it:
Let them row their boats to the walls and back. There’s no way out for them except the way we offer: to learn to feed and shelter themselves in this environment—to become self-sustaining. When they’ve done that, we’ll take them to Earth and let them go (200).
Lilith is not convinced and worries about the “troublemaker” humans now that they have all been brought to this place that seems so much like Earth. Lilith advocates putting Curt back to sleep, convinced that he will attack his ooloi as soon as he gets the chance. This is confirmed by Gabriel, who understands that Curt feels violated and powerless, which goes against his personality: “‘Look at things from Curt’s point of view,’ Gabriel said. ‘He’s not in control of even what his own body does and feels. He’s taken like a woman […] He can’t let them get away with that’” (203). Again, there are elements of sexism in this, as Curt cannot accept feeling like less than a “real” man through his experiences with the Oankali. This suggests the ways in which The Human Desire for Freedom can be culturally gendered; the aspiration toward liberation and agency may be universal, but many societies do not treat it as such, regarding violations of men’s autonomy much more seriously than violations of women’s.
Lilith doggedly keeps saying that her personal experiences have all led her to believe the Oankali, but even she feels some doubt sneaking into her mind: “What if, in spite of all she had seen and felt, this was some kind of hoax?” (207). Lilith cannot imagine how the Oankali could manage to have perpetuated such a deception or understand why they would. Ultimately, Lilith decides that she has to believe the basic elements of what she has been shown about the ship, but she is still left with the nagging doubt that she could be wrong.
Chapter 3 substantiates of one the greatest fears that Lilith had when she first found out about her role as the leader of the first human group: that she would be seen as a betrayer, a Judas goat who was selling out her people to aliens. Now, even Tate seems to insinuate that Lilith cares too much for Nikanj: “I don’t mean anything by this, but I have to say it. You and Nikanj […] You’re closer to him—to it—than we are to Kahguyaht. You…” (210) Tate does not finish her thought, but Lilith feels a level of accusation. This is part of the reason that she chooses to leave with her friends: to prove that she chooses humanity over the Oankali. The perceptions she faces as a Black woman make her position more difficult, highlighting the theme of Women of Color in Leadership Roles.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Octavia E. Butler