28 pages • 56 minutes read
Isis Watts, or Isie, is the story’s protagonist. As an 11-year-old, Isis spends her time playing outside and daydreaming of fairytales rather than doing her chores and behaving as a “lady” should. Due to their differences, Isis does not get along well with Grandma Potts. Hurston describes her young character as “the little brown figure” who spends her time “perched upon the gate post” watching cars drive by her home on their way to Orlando (45). This initial introduction illustrates the childlike innocence and perspective that Isis carries with her throughout the story. Because of Hurston’s background, many critics believe that Isis is an autobiographical depiction of Hurston’s childhood self.
Not only does Isis exude a cheerful demeanor, but she also serves as a figure of light. The other characters view her as “Isie the joyful,” especially those outside of her family like Jim Robinson and Helen. The name “Isis” refers to the Egyptian goddess of healing and magic, and this mythology situates her as a maternal figure despite her youth. By naming her after such a prominent figure in mythology, Hurston implies that Isis symbolizes a healing light for those around her. This connection provides insight as to why Helen feels pulled to Isis as if she were a child herself and not vice versa. Isis has the ability to induce many positive emotions in those around her. Hurston uses Isis as a reminder that joy can be found despite social stigma and prejudices against race and class.
Isis views the world from a child’s perspective, which is illustrated through her daydreams about Hercules, princesses, and riding horses to the horizon. By existing in a world of fairy tales, Isis believes she can achieve anything, so she moves through her day with confidence. Despite causing mischief for her grandmother, Isis behaves with curiosity and hopefulness, trusting the adults who want to take her out dancing. The race, class, and gender prejudices that affect Grandma Potts don’t penetrate Isis’s consciousness, suggesting that these impulses are learned rather than innate.
The third-person point of view only provides insight into Isis’s perspective, so the reader has limited knowledge of other characters’ thoughts. Grandma Potts is described as having a “straggling beard” on her chin that “curled here and there against the dark brown skin” (48). From this image, the narrator illustrates an unappealing image of the old woman, which reflects how Isis views her grandmother. Their relationship exists in such tension that Grandma Potts’s outward appearance unsettles Isis and causes her to pity her.
Grandma Potts presents herself as a strict, elderly woman who has high expectations for Isis. She serves as a foil for Isis’s joyous, energetic behavior, and the narrator portrays her as rigid and intentional in how she goes about her daily life. She sticks to a routine that is confined to her home. Grandma Potts not only stays within these boundaries, but she also does not view the white shell road as full of potential possibilities as Isis does.
Since the narrator tells this story through Isis’s limited perspective as a child, Grandma Potts appears to be unfair regarding how she expects Isis to behave. She believes in adhering to stereotypical gender roles and that children must respect their elders and do as they are told, which stems from the socially acceptable gender stereotypes during this time. Throughout the story, she fights with Isis and constantly threatens to whip her. She does not allow Isis to act like a child and expects her to maintain the house. If Isis is not doing chores, she expects her to sit quietly, which does not seem to be the expectation for Joel, Isis’s brother.
Helen maintains a lighthearted disposition similar to Isis and opposite to Grandma Potts, which paints Helen as a different type of maternal figure for Isis. Helen is characterized through her different dialect, which is more proper, and by her and her friends’ car; these factors indicate that she is wealthier than the Potts family. By paying for the tablecloth as a way to take Isis with her, Helen employs her higher social and economic status to ensure she receives what she wants. Although this can appear exploitative, Helen also seems to enjoy Isis for who she is. She provides Isis with “a voluntary act of love” by squeezing her hand in support and allowing her to experience life outside of the boundaries of her home. Helen’s character provides an opportunity for Isis, aligning her with the white shell road’s promise.
Similar to Isis, Helen’s name reflects a mythological figure, Helen of Troy. Known to be the most beautiful woman in Troy, whose beauty caused the Trojan War, Hurston’s Helen encapsulates a similar enthrallment for Isis. Hurston quickly illustrates Helen and the two men she arrives with at the carnival, as “suppressing mirth discreetly behind gloved hands,” implying that they are looking at the scene of Isis dancing in amusement (51). Immediately, Helen and Isis are drawn together. However, the reader knows very little of Helen and her intentions. By maintaining a close perspective on Isis, the narrator only provides insight into Helen through how Isis takes in the scene. From her actions, Helen appears to gravitate toward the young girl because she “is joy itself” and claims to “like her as she is” (54). While these are all pleasant sentiments, Helen’s language also implies that her interest in Isis is self-absorbed and not as benevolent as it seems.
Joel Watts is a flat character who illustrates how Isis and Joel have different gender roles. Being a flat character, Joel is not a prominent figure in the story and does not develop or change. Other than being “next older than Isis” (48), Hurston does not provide much context for who Joel is. For the limited time he is in the story, he is shown having fun like asking Isis to go fishing with him or conspiring with Isis to shave Grandma Potts’s chin. It seems that Isis bears the brunt of the punishment for the latter incident, and at one point, Grandma Potts asks Joel to fetch something with which to whip. Through these instances, the narrator establishes that Joel has a privileged position in the house as a son. He does not worry about chores and does what he wants without fear of consequences. His main function as Isis’s brother is to illustrate the stereotypical gender norms Grandma Potts upholds.
As her older brother, Joel holds power over Isis, which furthers the gendered stereotypes that exist in the story. When they go to shave their grandmother’s chin, he claims that Isis does not know anything about shaving unlike him because he is a boy. Unlike Isis, Joel buys into the gender hierarchy because it benefits him. He does not have to question where he stands in his own house and is left to his own devices, unlike his little sister.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Zora Neale Hurston