60 pages • 2 hours read
Bohannon tells the story of an old woman who lived in Jericho over 8,500 years ago. She helps deliver her granddaughter’s baby but soon discovers that the infant is coming out foot first. She recalls how dangerous the breeched births she has seen were, with both mother and baby dying in one case and the baby surviving but the mother dying in another case. She places her hand into her granddaughter’s body.
Bohannon describes menopause and its mark of the end of a female person’s fertility. The impact menopause has on a person’s body is so drastic because the ovaries and their associated sex hormones play an important role in every aspect of the female body. She asks why nature would have an otherwise healthy female person stop being fertile once she reaches a certain age.
She hypothesizes that nature must end female fertility earlier than male fertility so that they can take on the role of the grandmother. Menopause may have been meant to create grandmothers to care for the children. These grandmothers would provide free childcare for mothers and dote on the children, as is a common experience children have with their grandmothers. She notes that there are many species in which there are non-reproducing members who help care for the young, such as worker ants. Bohannon remembers donating her eggs to a professor couple with whom she is friends. The woman was already in her forties, and her doctor said that she no longer had any good eggs. Bohannon explores the hypothesis that female humans evolved to reach menopause once they lost too many good eggs and that female humans start losing so many eggs so early because many of them might be immature or defective. She also explains that the reason while male individuals stay fertile much longer than female individuals is because sperm is made of less material than eggs. Therefore, more things can go wrong with eggs, especially as a female individual ages, including an increased risk of the child being born with Down syndrome. However, she adds in the footnotes that older sperm can cause problems as well, with male individuals over 40 being more likely to father a child with chromosomal abnormalities, autism, schizophrenia, or Down syndrome. She also states that older female individuals are more likely to suffer early miscarriages.
She then returns to the story about the old woman in Jericho. The woman decides to push the foot back, dislocating her granddaughter’s hip in the process. She successfully turns the infant around. She safely delivers her granddaughter’s infant son but must wait to see if her granddaughter will recover.
Bohannon concludes that the purpose of menopause is so that older female individuals, including grandmothers, can provide wisdom that will help the community. They have life experience and can remember important events in the group’s history, helping them navigate famines, agricultural problems, illnesses, and other problems. She uses the story of Afghani shop owner and former soldier Abedo, who fought with the mujahedin against the Soviet Union and later commanded a private army against the Taliban. Because female individuals live much longer than male individuals, this makes grandmothers and other older female individuals even more important. She uses the history of the people of Jericho burying their dead under their houses and songs released in wartimes. Bohannon thinks about her older brother and is unsure how she will handle his death. She concludes that menopause is about female individuals having to outlive the male individuals they love, whether they be husbands, lovers, brothers, or friends.
Bohannon recalls seeking a phone job and finding out that it was for an escort service. The madam then encouraged her to become one of the employees there. She entertained the idea, not understanding why it would be such a problem for her to do sex work if it was just business to her. However, after her boyfriend threatened to end the relationship, she chose not to take the job, deciding that she would rather keep his love. Bohannon then explains that she is not the Eve of love, and there likely is not one; however, every female individual is an Eve, and all play a role in female human evolution. She thinks back to two things her mentors told her: First, people’s ability to love is what makes them human—not just romantically or sexually, but platonically as well. Second, both sex work and marriage come from apes trading meat for sex. Scientists and other people have tried to discover the true nature of love and sex, but no one has been able to agree.
Bohannon dismisses polygyny as the dominant evolutionary origin of human love and sex because humans do not have the physical markers of a polygynous species. Unlike gorillas, humans do not have large canines used to intimidate competing males or the overwhelming difference in weight between the sexes. The ancestors who were larger and had harems were most likely distant ancestors before the formation of hominins. Thus, she concludes that polygyny is a recent development in human sexuality. She then explores the possibility of hominins being promiscuous like chimpanzees and bonobos. Bohannon notes, however, that male individuals have medium-sized testicles and that promiscuous primates have large testicles. Promiscuous male mammals will also use a seminal plug to cover a female’s cervix. Humans do not produce this plug. Bohannon then wonders if hominins’ evolutionary past involved rape. Though male chimpanzees are sometimes coercive and physically abusive toward female partners, hominin anatomy and primatology do not show rape as a common behavior.
Hominin males also do not appear to have been highly competitive, with scientists believing that hominins developed monogamy to protect females’ children in exchange for sexual exclusivity. However, the danger of infanticide by males was common, and so female primates use promiscuity to protect their babies. Male-dominated primate species such as chimps and gorillas frequently killed opponents’ babies, and to prevent infanticide, early hominins needed to be matriarchal. Bonobos are highly promiscuous, but babies’ paternity is unknown. They are also highly protective of their babies. To answer the question of how monogamy started, Bohannon theorizes that dominant males formed relationships with females’ babies, as seen with baboons, and, like geladas, formed male-dominant groups. She then hypothesizes that as hominins evolved and childbirth became more dangerous, females chose to become monogamous in exchange for protection for their babies.
Bohannon believes that female individuals were essential in the dominant model of humanity, switching from matriarchal and matrilineal to patriarchal and patrilineal. She hypothesizes that female individuals agreed to allow male dominance and sexism as a compromise. She also uses the commonality of internalized misogyny as an example of how women contribute to misogyny and patriarchal structures. However, Bohannon asserts that sexism has outlived its evolutionary usefulness and is making humans less healthy, less prosperous, and less intelligent.
The double standards of patriarchal sexual mores, which reward male promiscuity but punish female promiscuity, have led to an increase in sexually transmitted diseases, of which male individuals tend to experience fewer symptoms. Sexism has also led to more cases of child marriage and people having children far sooner than is safe for them, leading to higher maternal and child mortality rates. Medical misogyny and restrictions on female reproductive choice have harmed female individuals greatly, making it more difficult for them to live to have healthy children. Sexism has also limited communities’ prosperity by keeping female individuals from obtaining educations and contributing to their communities’ wealth. Male individuals are more likely to spend money on weapons, entertainment, and gambling, while female individuals are more likely to spend money on healthcare, childcare, food, clothing, and education. The lack of female individuals in education and the professional world is limiting communities’ and the world’s economic potential, as seen with the difference between Kerala, which is prospering and has a large number of educated female individuals, and Bihar, which has fewer educated female individuals and has less prosperity. Furthermore, malnourishment makes it harder for children’s brains to grow. Indian states where young female individuals are made to eat last have large numbers of malnourished female individuals. Female malnourishment also reduces the brain health of mothers and their babies. In addition, cultures with higher gender equality, such as the Arab world during Islam’s Golden Age in the Middle Ages, have seen greater gender equality and large amounts of innovation along with high education and literacy levels. Meanwhile, places where female education is undervalued often suffer from lack of education and innovations.
Bohannon says that eliminating sexism will be difficult, but it must be done because it is hurting the human race and the world. She says that it is possible, but people must combat disasters like climate change that will make these problems worse, and horrible people can endanger progress and create long-lasting problems for humanity as it tries to combat problems like sexism.
Bohannon says that humans must use their social skills, problem-solving skills, and institutions to combat sexism and the problems to which it contributes. She then talks about explaining this to the madam who tried to pimp her. She adds that the madam likely did not see her actions as wrong and that she does not hold any animosity toward her. She says she would explain to the madam that she should donate her large amounts of money to female education and female healthcare. She then concludes that female individuals give male individuals much of the power over them and assures her female audience that they can stop giving away their power.
Chapters 8 and 9 mark the concluding chapters of the book and, thus, establish some of the more recent developments in human evolution. The Evolution and Historical Impact of the Female Body is addressed as Bohannon argues that humans developed the life phase of menopause to provide non-reproducing older female individuals who will guide their communities and help them solve problems using memories and experience from their lives. Because female individuals live longer than male individuals, these older female humans are essential in their communities. They provide wisdom from their lives and use their knowledge of crops, local history, and other areas to combat problems such as famines, land disputes, conflicts, and disease outbreaks. Throughout human history, cultures have relied on wise older women for advice and solutions, which has helped them persevere.
The human body also shows that hominin society had likely once been matriarchal. This allowed male and female hominins to have relatively straightforward sex organs and a fairly safe environment for mothers to raise their babies. This indicates that hominin sex was mostly consensual and that humanity has been able to evolve in a way that has allowed male and female couples, and couples of the same sex, to have sex and fall in love in fulfilling and healthy ways. The final chapter group also explores The Intersection of Science and Gender. The differences in male sperm production and female egg production and the existence of menopause have led to fertility treatments such as egg donation, which Bohannon mentions doing for a middle-aged couple in the past. In addition, scientists have been studying the origins of human love and sexuality and how gender affects it. Female hominins’ decision to at some point allow the implementation of sexism to enforce monogamy in exchange for the protection of their babies from other males has had the negative effect of allowing human societies to evolve into highly patriarchal structures where male individuals are valued over female individuals and female desires, bodies, and lives are disregarded to the point of biological carelessness. This same sexism has allowed people in science and medicine to ignore and neglect female biology.
Throughout Chapter 9, Bohannon uses rhetoric to persuade her readers that while sexism and patriarchal structures might have benefitted humanity sometime in the past, it is now becoming a serious problem damaging female fertility, robbing female individuals of contributing to their communities, and limiting female brain growth. She uses the prevalence of undetected sexually transmitted infection transmissions from male promiscuity and forced female chastity, the marriage and impregnation of underage female individuals, and restrictions on reproductive choice, including birth control and abortion, as examples of how sexism against female individuals is harming their reproductive health. Thus, they are less likely to survive pregnancies and have healthy babies when they are ready. She also shows the link between female education and employment and economic prosperity, showing that more gender-egalitarian places have higher prosperity and wealth. Then, she uses Indian women’s struggles with malnutrition as an example of how underfeeding female individuals can diminish important brain growth. Sexism is no longer good for humanity, if it ever was good for humanity, and Bohannon wants her readers to acknowledge it and work toward changing it. She concludes the book by telling her female readers that female individuals have given male individuals much of the dominance they have. Female individuals can thus choose to stop sexist male individuals if they stand and work together.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
Anthropology
View Collection
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Family
View Collection
Feminist Reads
View Collection
Health & Medicine
View Collection
Nature Versus Nurture
View Collection
Science & Nature
View Collection
The Past
View Collection
Women's Studies
View Collection