67 pages • 2 hours read
Katharina spots Jens on the platform to West Germany and approaches him. Jens refuses to acknowledge her. Traveling to Cologne to meet her relatives, Katharina gets her first glimpses of the West’s commercialism.
Katharina’s aunt, Annie, had entered West Germany in 1961 to spend one night with her fiancé, Manfred. The following day, the construction of the Berlin Wall left her stranded. Katharina’s grandmother, Emmi, now lives in a basement apartment, which she moved into five years earlier to live closer to Annie. She has replicated the interior of her East Berlin apartment in the new one. Despite their distance, Katharina has maintained correspondence with Annie’s daughter, her cousin Katrin.
While touring Cologne with her relatives, Katharina spots several street beggars. Although she has nothing to give, she is moved by the sight of them. She is later disturbed that her relatives do not feel the same way. Manfred goes so far as to chide the beggars for being lazy.
Katrin introduces Katharina to her boyfriend, Christian, at a McDonald’s, where Katrin explains how she passed her bank job interview by performing reverence for Adenauer. Katharina repeats what Hans told her about Adenauer’s role in the failure to reunify Germany. Katrin discourages her from being with someone as old as Hans.
Katharina is amazed by the cheap cost of quality goods in West Germany. Emmi praises her fashion sense and financial savvy. Katharina misses Hans, who does not call her, because he is on vacation with his family.
During Emmi’s birthday, Manfred asks Katharina if she is enjoying her “freedom.” Katharina is reluctant to answer, even as her relatives tempt her with the prospect of visiting a museum of Roman ruins. When Katharina laments Hans’s absence from her life, Emmi tells her how she learned that her husband, Karl, had another family in Norway. Despite their long marriage, she feels that she never really knew her husband that well.
On her last day in Cologne, Katharina indulges her curiosity and enters a sex shop. She is both viscerally excited and sickened by its catalogue of sex toys and graphic images. She keeps thinking of the sex shop as a place devoid of innocence, where desires are indulged by money. She continues to wait for Hans’s call, which never comes.
On his vacation along the Baltic coast, Hans is unable to call Katharina, because the only telephone in the hotel would draw his family’s attention. Hans spends the vacation trying to lose himself in relaxing activities, but he struggles to control his desires. During a day visit to Barth, Hans tells his family about a poem inscribed on one of the fountains. He barely holds their interest. He and Ingrid bicker over the poem’s assertion that poets must deny their individual desires, much to Ludwig’s annoyance.
Hans fears that Katharina may want to end their relationship because he hasn’t called.
Katharina goes to the Baltic coast to surprise Hans. She sees Hans’s family in person for the first time, though they do not realize she is there for him. Hans slips away from his family to spend an intimate moment with Katharina. Later that night, they have sex.
The next day, Hans tells Katharina about his childhood. During World War II, Hans’s father taught German values to Polish prisoners. Hans himself was in the Hitler Youth. It was not long after when he first saw footage of how the prisoners were being treated in the concentration camps. Katharina recalls her own grandfather, who escaped being killed by the Nazis and by the fascists in Spain. Had he died, Katharina would not have been born. From Katharina’s perspective, the history of Germany from before she was born has always been marked by violence and death.
Amid extensive public renovations in East Berlin, Hans and Katharina spend almost every day together. Katharina’s father visits from Leipzig and is impressed by Hans. He encourages her to learn from his materialist view of history. Hans feels that the Berlin of his youth is being demolished, leaving him to hold on to his ideals as the last relic of his youth. Katharina is the only other reminder he has left of what it means to be young. Hans anticipates the inevitability of his death.
Katharina invites Hans over to the apartment she lives in with her mother and her stepfather, Ralph, while they are away. When Hans sees the bed in Katharina’s room, he gets the idea to tie her to it as a sex game. She agrees to the idea almost immediately. Once he finishes tying Katharina to the bed, Hans leaves the room to smoke. He explains that he did this to assert the exciting power of possibility, knowing that he could go to the room anytime and see her there. Katharina taunts that he is scared she will run away. Hans orders her to turn to her side, then he strikes her with his belt. Afterward, he kisses the parts he struck.
Katharina feels that she truly knows Hans now. She fantasizes about being the mother of his child.
Three months into their relationship, Katharina starts becoming possessive of Hans. Some of her habits have begun to merge with his. She adopts his writing style and gets rid of the records she used to listen to in order to feel sad. She feels she is both merging with Hans and becoming both her true self. When Hans shows her pictures of his 50th birthday party, Katharina becomes suspicious of the other women in his life. She is upset that Hans remains married to Ingrid.
While Katharina is out with friends, Hans spends an evening alone at a café called the Arkade, where he contemplates the time he has left with Katharina. He acknowledges that she is jealous about the effort she has to put into keeping their relationship secret, which none of his other lovers have to do. He writes a letter to Katharina, detailing his observations of the café. The letter includes other stray thoughts, including his hopes to make something more of their relationship. Thinking about Katharina with her male friends, Hans realizes he is possessive of her as well. The “serene” period of their relationship has ended.
While with her friends, Katharina can only talk about Hans. Her friends laugh off her reverence for his gestures. One friend, André, comments that Katharina is too dependent on Hans. Hans is only giving a part of himself to her, not the whole. Another friend, Ruth, comments that Katharina has lost her “radiance” ever since she started dating Hans. Katharina is unsure what she means.
Katharina is crestfallen with her friends’ disapproval. She now feels her relationship with Hans is necessary for her to stand “against the world” (108).
As Christmas comes around, Hans fears that he will have to withdraw from Katharina again to spend time with his family. Hans considers giving Katharina the excuse he typically uses when he has to neglect his lovers to spend time with his wife—“Without my marriage I wouldn’t be the man I am” (109)—but realizes that it would mean something different in their affair. The marriage and the affair mutually improve each other, making Katharina seem more exciting and Ingrid more beautiful in her anger toward Hans. For her part, Ingrid manages both their household and Hans’s practical needs from day to day. Most importantly, Ingrid has chosen to stay with him in spite of his affairs.
Hans concludes that his marriage makes him the man that Katharina loves. He worries that his excuse would lead to her continued frustration, followed by encouragements from her loved ones to leave him.
After Ingrid throws him out, Hans stays at the apartment of a friend who has fled to West Germany. He struggles to get by on the 500 marks Ingrid gave him for his expenses, though he does not feel the disposition to work. He focuses on trying to make his groceries and his budget last through the winter.
Katharina stays with him now that they no longer have to sneak around. They settle into a regular routine, in which Hans writes to her and asks her to write back about her wants. All she knows is that she wants to be with him and to have a child.
Hans supposes that he will need to end one of his relationships to save the other. He writes an idealized version of his predicament in which both relationships can mutually exist. He wonders if he needs Ingrid because she fulfills his living needs while Katharina fulfills his sexual needs. He does not share these thoughts with Katharina.
In these chapters, the relationship between Hans and Katharina exits what Hans refers to as its “serene” phase. The tensions that were implied by the conditions of their relationship have now become overt and active obstacles. This transition is marked by several plot developments, namely Katharina’s travel to West Germany, the introduction of BDSM play into her relationship with Hans, and Ingrid’s discovery of Hans’s affair.
Katharina’s visit to West Germany exposes her to a radically different lifestyle and perspective of the world. All her life, she has grown up insulated within the socialist culture of East Germany. As a result, she is scandalized not only by the poverty she witnesses in West Germany, but by the indifferent and sometimes disdainful attitude her relatives have toward those in poverty. On the other hand, she is also shocked with the way the capitalist economy affects her access to quality goods. This culminates in her visit to the sex shop, where she first encounters the commodification of sex and love. Putting a price on sex within the capitalist system of supply and demand pushes Katharina to believe that nothing can be off-limits between herself and Hans. If West Germans are willing to put a price on sexual acts that others might consider taboo, then it encourages her to engender new, equally forbidden desires. She exercises this appetite for transgression for the first time when she decides to surprise Hans on his family vacation, which he welcomes with open arms.
Katharina’s experiences in West Germany also lead her to become possessive of Hans. In her view, Hans should belong only to her, and she equates this desire for monogamy with the capitalist valorization of private property. This view becomes clear in light of the jealousy she feels toward Ingrid and Hans’s other lovers. She has to do the work of keeping their affair secret, which none of the other women have to do, and this secrecy signals to her that their relationship is lower in value. Her indulgence of Hans’s sadomasochistic desires is a way for her to set herself apart from his other partners. The negotiation of value against Hans’s validation points to Identity and Power in the Context of Romantic Love as a theme. It stresses Katharina’s need to navigate the discrepancy between Hans’s words and actions in order to determine her personal value.
Conversely, Hans’s desire for BDSM play serves for him as a way to deal with the violence that marked his childhood. As the world shifts around him, with the Berlin he knew giving way to a new Germany, he becomes insecure about his age and mortality. His relationship with Katharina is the last material relic he has of his youth, which suggests his need to impart a more abstract relic—his ideals and values—to her. In this way, their relationship exemplifies The Generational Divide Against the Backdrop of History as a theme. When he ties her to the bed in an erotic game, the moment suggests that their sexual lives will serve as a way for Hans to act out his political history—including the elements of control and violence as well as tenderness and care.
Once Ingrid discovers Hans’s affair and throws him out, Hans realizes the power that Ingrid has over him. She makes her own unique value clear, which forces Hans to make a choice between her and Katharina. Hans concludes that neither relationship can entirely be considered the right one, because each of them responds to different needs. His inability to choose and his desire to maintain both relationships at once reveal his anxiety to participate in The Politics of Transgression and Atonement, another major theme of the novel. With Katharina, Hans compulsively enacts his authority as the arbiter of transgression and atonement. Later, after her tryst with Vadim, he extracts endless confessions and ever more formally rigorous apologies from her. But when he is the one who has transgressed, he is unwilling to be held accountable.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features: