53 pages • 1 hour read
Summary
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
Jenna recalls a conversation between her parents when she was very young. They are debating about whether any species of animal is truly monogamous. Her father says a male penguin finds a perfect pebble and then gives it to his chosen partner. They remain together for life. Her father picks up a pebble and presents it to her mother.
Jenna switches her attention to Virgil. She speculates that because he drinks so much, he might not be able to handle a proper investigation. She forces him to ride on the back of her bicycle and takes him to a local diner for coffee, to sober up. He advances the theory that her mother might have killed Nevvie and run off. It takes a few moments for Jenna to process that scenario. Virgil tells her to meet him at 11 o’clock the following morning, to see if they can analyze the red hair found on Nevvie’s body.
Jenna returns to her grandmother’s house and asks why nobody performed a search for Alice. Her grandmother admits that she went to the police station several times but never had the courage to go inside and make a report, as she was afraid to learn what the police might find out. She speculates that perhaps her daughter didn’t want to be found.
The next day, Jenna and Virgil sneak into the police station to retrieve the evidence from the night of Nevvie’s death. Among the items, Jenna finds a small, pink Converse sneaker. She and her mother both wore that same brand and color of footwear. She recognizes the shoe as her own and realizes she was there when the accident occurred, even though she can’t remember it occurring.
Virgil takes the red hair to a DNA analyst named Tallulah. He has to sweet talk her into performing a swab test on Jenna, to see if there’s a match. This would prove the hair belonged to Alice. They must wait a few days for the results to come back from the lab. Jenna fears that the results might prove her mother was a murderer.
Alice discusses elephant empathy. She mentions how an entire herd will figure out a strategy to get a youngster out of a tricky situation. In one case, an elephant with a mutilated trunk was fed by other members of his herd. In another instance, a matriarch chose to allow a lioness and her cubs to cross her path without charging them.
Despite these instances of generosity, elephants will usually refuse to nurse an orphaned calf because milk is a scarce commodity meant only for biological offspring. However, Alice recalls one instance when a matriarch comes across an abandoned calf. She tries to drive him away but ultimately relents and adopts him. Alice concludes that this is proof of the special empathy elephants have for mothers and babies.
Serenity recalls her own mother’s death after Serenity became famous. Even though she helped many who had passed on, Serenity is never able to contact her mother. One day, her mother materializes in the passenger seat of her car, looking the way Serenity remembered her as a child, and not as a frail and aged woman. Serenity believes spirits appear to the living in whatever form they choose.
Serenity goes to an Apple store because her printer is jammed. The techie who tries to fix it releases a print queue of gibberish except for one word: Jenna. Serenity takes this as a sign, but she doesn’t know what it means.
Serenity calls Jenna and suggests they go back to the place where they found Alice’s wallet. Virgil is also part of the team and skeptical that Serenity can help. As they again search the preserve, Serenity tells Jenna that spirits don’t always wait around for their loved ones on the other side. Souls exist at various levels of development, and some move to a higher level more quickly than others.
When the trio arrives at the pond where Nevvie was trampled, Serenity draws their attention to an object in the mud. Virgil retrieves a pebble necklace that once belonged to Alice. Jenna says that Alice never took it off. Virgil suggests that they visit Thomas in the asylum to see if the necklace can jog his memory about what happened that night.
Serenity isn’t pleased by the prospect of visiting a mental institution, as she recalls the time when she checked herself into a psych ward years earlier. She considers that she “may be coming face-to-face with people who can’t control a natural gift I’d kill to have once again” (154). Eventually, the psychic deals with her own issues and agrees that they should all visit Jenna’s father.
In these chapters, the trio of fractious personalities begins to coalesce as a team. Both Serenity and Virgil are still resistant to the idea of helping Jenna because her quest holds high personal stakes for each of them.
If Serenity can’t psychically find any more clues, this is further proof that she’s lost her intuitive gift and is washed up. If Virgil can’t connect the dots with the clues that are given him, this is proof that he can’t follow an investigation through to its conclusion. Since neither one believes they can successfully give Jenna the answers she wants, each one fears the feelings of humiliation, defeat, and loss that this failed effort will create.
Alice’s anecdote about elephant behavior once again draws a parallel to the investigation. She describes an elephant matriarch who unwillingly adopts a stray calf because she can’t overcome her own sense of empathy for a lost child. So, too, Serenity and Virgil ultimately overcome their fear of failure because they empathize with Jenna, who is another lost child.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Jodi Picoult