43 pages • 1 hour read
While reading Charlie’s journal entries, Silas finds an account of one of their past dates. They went to Bourbon Street and met a man painted silver, who answered questions for quarters. Silas asked for the meaning of life, and the street performer answered with “All there is left to do now is dance” (324). Caught up in the moment, the couple proceeded to do just that. This is the moment in which Charlie fell in love. Later, in the present, the couple play “Silas Says,” and Silas commands Charlie to dance with him: “We sway softly back and forth, and dance to non-existent music right down the middle of Bourbon Street” (336).
Dancing thus emerges as a symbol of Charlie and Silas’s love, reckless and spontaneous, public yet intensely private. As they whirl around shocked and stunned faces, they treasure their world apart. So caught up in their love, they do not need music, instead moving to the subtle rhythm of each other’s bodies. In a way, this dance proves more intimate than Charlie and Silas’s recent kisses, and because they experience pain the most when they do not listen to their hearts, dancing symbolizes the joy of being true to oneself and one’s love.
In a novel in which dreams reveal truths and intuition is never wrong, Charlie and Silas’s love story finds purchase at a tarot shop. Their initial visit is key because the mysterious tarot reader is none other than Charlie’s father’s lover who he abandoned and the mother of Charlie’s half sister Cora. The shop’s atmosphere endows Never Never with a supernatural tone. The shop, with its candles and knick-knacks, transports Charlie and a skeptical Silas to another world. Among the items is a framed photo that mirrors Silas’s own photo of a gate outside of a house, later revealed to be Charlie’s original home of Jamais Jamais (French for “Never Never”). Janice’s theatrical performance further enhances the atmosphere, especially when Charlie’s outcome card turns up blank.
The blank card symbolizes a way to allow love, life itself, some spontaneity; tarot cards can only predict so much. While Charlie and Silas seem destined to be together, their fathers’ fallout did deter their relationship for years. Circumstances can change, and it takes work to meet desirable ends—soul mates or not. The art of tarot symbolizes agency as much as destiny, as much of Charlie and Silas’s futures are left to their own designs, their own decisions.
While struggling to understand the amnesia loops, Charlie experiences a moment of clarity when she spots her own tattoo—that of a silhouetted grove of trees. Upon removing Silas’s shirt, she finds a tattoo in the same place, though his depicts a string of black pearls. She feels soothed, having found connection. Amid the loops, the pair’s tattoos symbolize the permanence of love in an otherwise uncertain world. For Charlie in particular, agreeing to a tattoo as someone who fears pain and risk of infection is her way of showing her commitment to Silas. The tattoos thus become lasting, reassuring reminders that they’ll always have each other’s backs.
Because neither teen’s family approves of their relationship, they choose subtle, symbolic representations of their names—with “Silas” deriving from the Greek word for “forest” (Charlie’s tattoo) and Charlie’s middle name, Margaret, deriving from the Greek word for “pearl” (Silas’s tattoo). In addition to symbolizing the permanence of their love, the tattoos suggest intimacy, a secret to keep out the forces that drive them apart. Silas tells his mother that his tattoo represents the pearly gates of heaven, while Charlie tells her mother that her tattoo represents her love of the earth. In this, the tattoos allow the lovers a space of their own.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By these authors
Coming-of-Age Journeys
View Collection
Fate
View Collection
Friendship
View Collection
Memory
View Collection
New York Times Best Sellers
View Collection
Order & Chaos
View Collection
Romance
View Collection
Valentine's Day Reads: The Theme of Love
View Collection
YA Horror, Thrillers, & Suspense
View Collection