46 pages • 1 hour read
Baldwin returns to New York in 1957. He intends to travel south, but remains in New York for a time to save money for the trip. He begins to see New York through a different lens and reconsiders his connection to the city. After a while, he leaves for the South.
For Baldwin, the South is both beautiful and terrifying. He learns “to live with his fears” and realizes his own limits (52). He also gains insight into the emotional state of Americans. He emphasizes America’s “emotional poverty” and people’s inability to connect their public and personal lives, which impacts the relations between white and Black Americans. White Americans are afraid to confront their inner selves; thus the white imagination has made Black people a “scapegoat” and an invented problem. Still, white Americans cannot escape reality. Traveling south, Baldwin witnesses the destruction of white Americans’ inner lives and their “sorrow.” He believes that the possibility of America’s rebirth lies in the South, as it reveals the reality of the conflict between Black and white people.
During his time in the South, Baldwin participates in the civil rights movement and tours cities. The predominance of terror in the South shows Baldwin Black people’s “pride,” “rage,” and, ultimately, their defiance of death. They are passionate about their cause and do not—cannot—retreat from their struggle. He is astonished to realize that death is a daily threat for Black southerners. He sees the struggles for integration in education and the limitations of the American education system, which prioritizes white American history and culture.
Baldwin recalls being sexually harassed by a prominent southern man. He connects this event to power, manhood, and the history of enslavement, when white male enslavers oppressed and emasculated Black men. White men are still controlled by their need to oppress Black manhood, and within the South, the question of manhood is central. Baldwin characterizes Black men as “heroic” for carrying on their daily lives under constant terror.
In the South, Baldwin feels like a foreigner but he still connects to the African American community. He spends a night exploring Montgomery, Alabama, during which he crosses “the racial dividing lines” by entering a restaurant via the front entrance (71). He soon leaves, not wanting to endanger the civil rights struggle by drawing attention to himself.
Baldwin arrives in Montgomery during the time of the marches and sit-in protests throughout the South and as major civil rights leaders like Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X are gaining national attention. Baldwin stresses Black people’s courage. However, he emphasizes that nonviolence is a “difficult” strategy against racial violence.
The rise of the civil rights movement leads Baldwin to return to the United States. As a native of New York, his first visit to the South is eye-opening. He sees it as a place of contradiction, recognizing both the courage of the Black community and the terror of white supremacy. Under constant threat of violence and racism in the South, Baldwin learns to live with his fears.
Drawing on his experience in the South, Baldwin analyzes the state of American consciousness. For Baldwin, America is characterized by a profound “emotional poverty” and a disconnection between the people’s “public stance” and their “private life.” Americans’ impoverished inner lives and their inability to form connections has impacted social life and the relations between Black and white people. Baldwin emphasizes that racism is a result of the white imagination and white Americans’ fear of themselves. The white imagination projected these inner fears and grievances onto Black people. However, as Baldwin notes, the oppression of Black people could not “purify” white American consciousness. Ultimately, white Americans lead problematic lives with equally problematic identities, which, due to America’s international influence, are a threat to the world. Therefore, the South represents the troubling inner lives of Americans as well as America’s possibilities for social change. Baldwin considers the putative freedom of the North an illusion, observing that northerners are always “locking the South within them” (56). Thus, the South makes American reality evident. Baldwin adds that Black people in the South understand the racial problem throughout America, while in the North, “opportunities for self-delusion [are] […] much greater” (76). He stresses that when white Americans’ delusions collapse, the South can spark America’s rebirth.
The terror Black southerners live with, which Baldwin also experiences during his visit, involves its own paradox. In the face of death, Black people showed defiance, courage, and “an overwhelming pride and rage” (58). The Role of Masculinity in the Racial Struggle is evident as Baldwin describes the bravery and perseverance of Black men in the South. Mentioning his sexual harassment by a powerful southern man, Baldwin notes that white men define themselves by the oppression of Black manhood. This practice began in the time of enslavement in America, when “the black man’s right to his women, as well as to his children, was simply taken from him” (62), and it continues to impact racial relations in the present. White men remain trapped in their own illusions and depend on the subjugation of Black men. He notes that if men do not honor one another’s manhood, “chaos arrives.” The issue of manhood is central for Baldwin, and the South in the 1950s highlights the question of “what a man is, should do, or become” (65). Despite his absence from America for years, Baldwin realizes his unbreakable connection to the African American community.
Baldwin notes that activism in Montgomery, Alabama, helped the civil rights movement grow, as protests spread from there throughout the South. Black activists came from diverse backgrounds and galvanized each other, at a great cost and facing constant violence, “to move, to march, and to vote” (80). Black people resolved to fight for equality because life under racism “was no way for a man or a woman or a child to live” (81). However, Baldwin began to realize that the strategy of nonviolence was a challenging path, alluding to the movement’s shift during the Black Power era.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By James Baldwin
Black History Month Reads
View Collection
Books on U.S. History
View Collection
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Civil Rights & Jim Crow
View Collection
Contemporary Books on Social Justice
View Collection
Essays & Speeches
View Collection
Inspiring Biographies
View Collection
Memoir
View Collection
Politics & Government
View Collection
Popular Study Guides
View Collection
Valentine's Day Reads: The Theme of Love
View Collection