43 pages • 1 hour read
Feeling anxious over her approaching dinner to meet Luke’s mother, Sophia seeks out her roommate to share her feelings. Marcia cautions Sophia that she might be taking her relationship with Luke too seriously too soon after her breakup with Brian. Rebound relationships seldom end in anything but disaster. Confused, Sophia heads to Luke’s ranch. Luke’s mother Linda welcomes Sophia warmly.
As Luke grills the steaks and Sophia watches Linda finish the dinner prep in the kitchen, she is reminded of her own mother and how much she misses her family. Linda tells Sophia that missing her family only means that they are close. Over dinner, Linda shares embarrassing stories of Luke when he was a boy. Sophia feels all over again the rightness of where she is despite what Marcia said. When Luke intuits that something bothers Sophia, she shares with him Marcia’s warning, but quickly dismisses it: “spending time with Luke not only was easy, but it felt indefinably right” (184). After dinner, Sophia watches Luke expertly carve a pumpkin. He invites her to help, hands her the knife, and then lovingly guides her hand. Although it crosses Sophia’s mind to spend the night with Luke in his cabin, she does not stay, “hungry [for the] promise of the future” (185).
Night is coming, and Ira panics. For the first time, he realizes he might die in his car. Ruth—always “stronger and smarter and better at everything” (187)—calms him. She tells him to close his eyes and imagine they are on a beach and that she is offering him a glass of cool water. It works. Ira relishes the slow pull of the imaginary gulps he takes. He remembers the summer of 1946 when he and Ruth decided to marry before Ruth started her teaching position at Greensboro.
They married in a traditional Jewish ceremony in August. For their honeymoon, they explored the foothills of the Blue Mountains around Asheville. Ruth suggested they visit the campus of Black Mountain College, which she knew from her father was renowned for its cutting-edge art department and its support of new artists. Ruth conducted a baffled Ira through the college’s art exhibits. The early Picassos and Pollocks seemed to him little more than “random colors and squiggly lines” (194). Lovingly, she shared with Ira what she knew about contemporary art. They stayed on the campus for several days, and when it came time to return to Greensboro, Ira surprised Ruth with six paintings he had purchased from the exhibit, among them an early de Kooning and a Picasso. Ira was not sure what they were or what they meant, but he loved how happy they made Ruth. It was not the art, but the shared experience. The purchase marked the beginning of what would be a vast collection—more than a thousand pieces, including important early works by Jasper Johns, Andy Warhol, and Mark Rothko.
Sophia will head home to New Jersey for the approaching holiday break. At the ranch, Luke cannot stop thinking about her. He is uncertain how he feels so deeply about a girl he really barely knows—how she could have come to mean so much to him so quickly. He drives to the campus every weekend.
One Sunday as they prepare to part for the week, Luke asks Sophia to spend a weekend with him at a small resort by a lake where his family used to vacation. She eagerly agrees. They load two horses in a trailer and drive two hours to the lake. After checking into their cabin, they take the horses out for a slow walk, “their vision wandering from one mountaintop to the next” (207). Sophia is awestruck by the panoramic vista.
When they return to their cabin from horseback riding, Sophia considers how drawn she is to Luke. He is the first real grown up she has dated, and she is over Brian’s frat boy charms: “It wasn’t until she met Luke that she realized how little she had really learned at school” (210). At a time when she is uncertain over where her life was going, time with Luke makes her feel as if she was “finally, truly moving forward somehow” (210). She knows in her heart that this feeling is love.
As the two share a bottle of Chardonnay over dinner, Luke awkwardly opens up about his traumatic experience riding Big Ugly Critter and the months of painful rehabilitation. He had no medical insurance, so he and his mother went deeply in debt to cover the bills. When Sophia asks about why Linda was so adamant about his not returning to competition, Luke stammers, refraining from sharing the grim medical prognosis and the risk he took returning to riding. For her part, Sophia shares the pain of Brian’s serial betrayals and how deeply hurt she was by him. In a moment of passion, Luke and Sophia exchange kisses and “I love yous,” and then Sophia takes Luke’s hand and leads him to the bedroom.
With the fast approach of darkness, Ira figures it has been an entire day “cocooned in silence, interred by the white hard cold of winter” (222). He is desperately thirsty. Ruth is quiet, but that quiet “was a passionate silence, one that had its roots in comfort and desire” (223).
He remembers returning from their honeymoon to set up their house in Greensboro, buying the furnishings, and attending to the necessary renovations to make “a house filled with love” (226). Ruth began teaching with trepidation. She feared her third-grade students might not accept her given her heavy Austrian accent. But after a few awkward days, they understood her approachability and responded to her sense of caring. Ira and Ruth continued to collect art even after Black Mountain College closed in the late 1950s. In 1956, Ira began a tradition he kept until Ruth’s death: Every year on their anniversary in August he would write her a letter telling her how much she meant to him and how much in love he was with her. In all, he wrote her 45 letters. Even after she died, he continued to write a letter every year on their anniversary to let her know that he “can’t live without her” (230).
As he sits in the wrecked truck, Ira acknowledges the sad fact that since Ruth’s death he has become “inconsequential” (231), an old man easy to ignore filling a shopping basket or pumping gas. He struggles against the weight of sadness. At that moment, Ruth tells him gently that he need not be so thirsty: There is snow on the windows—enough to keep him alive. Ira’s mouth “comes alive” (233) as he drinks the melted snow. Still tired and weak, he whispers that he loves Ruth. As he thinks about the art that he and Ruth collected over more than 40 years, valuable works by artist who went on to become major figures, he knows why despite repeated queries about selling all or parts of the collection he has kept it intact: The collection is the family they never had, the living manifestation of their love. “In those oils and pigments, I stored my memories of Ruth; in every painting I recall a chapter of our lives” (237).
For the first time since she arrived in Wake Forest, Sophia is genuinely happy. She has put out promising feelers to Denver and to New York for positions in art museums. Despite the winter break and the looming separation from Luke, she knows the “passion they felt for each other was intoxicating, something entirely different from what she’d felt with Brian” (239).
Her roommate again cautions Sophia that she and Luke have nothing in common; after graduation she will have to decide between a career as a museum curator and a ranch in the middle of nowhere: “I’m saying that you could be making a mistake. And that if you’re not careful, you could end up getting hurt” (242). These words hang over Sophia’s last visit with Luke before she leaves for New Jersey. Luke senses her unease. Sophia is not sure where the two of them are heading or what will happen when she graduates. Luke calmly reassures her that the two of them “will find a way to make it work” (245). Before she departs, he promises to drive to Trenton to meet her family on New Year’s Eve. Luke gives Sophia a Christmas present, an authentic cowboy hat decorated especially for her.
With the start of bull riding competition season only weeks away, Luke dedicates himself to training. He increases his exercise regimen and works out daily on the mechanical bull in the barn. He misses Sophia but focuses on the importance of winning to save the ranch. The eight-hour drive to Trenton gives Luke a chance to sort through his mixed feelings about returning to competition. He worries that if he rides hesitantly, too worried about falling, that lack of focus might cost him much more than the prize money. He feels guilty that he has not been entirely honest with Sophia and that his mother is upset over his decision to compete in one last season.
Meeting Sophia’s parents goes well. Luke begs Sophia to spend the night with him in his hotel, but Sophia thinks this would be inappropriate. When Luke returns to North Carolina, he doubles his practice sessions. He has a heartbreaking talk with his mother who begs him again to give up riding, but understands that, like his father, Luke is obsessed with riding and that he burns “with the desire to be the best” (254). In the end, however, Linda bluntly advises him to be honest with Sophia about the risks he is taking: “You should tell her that if you keep riding, you’ll most likely be dead in less than a year” (255).
Just as the previous chapters linked Ira and Luke through traditionally masculine traits, these chapters show us the commonalities between Ruth and Sophia, setting up a well-worn gender dynamic within each couple. The two women are more worldly, cultured, and educated than the men they fall in love with. Ruth comes from a family of intellectuals, speaks two languages, and grew up in Vienna—one of the cultural capitals of Europe—while Ira is a small-town southern shopkeeper. Ruth loves modernist art, while Ira’s clueless response to the tours of the Black Mountain College galleries marks him as a cultural neophyte. Similarly, Sophia longs for a career as a museum curator, steeped in history, culture, and erudition, while Luke knows nothing of intellectual pursuits or the art world.
In both relationships, the women must to some degree civilize the more rugged, less refined men, using their academic attainments not to further their own careers or intellectual pursuits, but to somewhat ornamentally temper the wildness of their male partners. Moreover, being with Ira and Luke means tamping down Ruth and Sophia’s ambitions. Ruth gives up her dream of motherhood and settles for being an elementary school teacher married to a shopkeeper. Sophia acts as though learning to carve a pumpkin is an artistic endeavor on par with her four years of college art history courses.
Though the novel focuses almost claustrophobically on just four people, this section slightly expands their world. We learn a bit about Sophia’s roommate Marcia, who here appears to be something like the voice of reason telling Sophia to slow down rather than going all-in on a rebound relationship. We also get a better sense of Luke’s mother Linda, who sees how much Luke takes after his bull riding father, but can’t help worrying about her son’s health and risk-taking behaviors.
The novel’s dreamy disregard of realism in favor of fantasy is most evident in its central conceit: that a man with no background in art who runs a mom-and-pop men’s clothing shop and a third-grade teacher employed in one of the more impoverished school districts in rural North Carolina could manage to amass a contemporary art collection worth hundreds of millions featuring works by Andy Warhol, Willem do Kooning, Jackson Pollock, and Mark Rothko. The novel sidesteps explaining this fantastical plot element by arguing that the canvasses come from the same miracle as Ruth and Ira’s love. In a final rejection of Ruth’s intellectual background, Ira tells a The New Yorker reporter, whom the novel mocks as a hopeless elitist, that this collection has nothing to do with art.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Nicholas Sparks