The Nature of the Beast

When the death of Laurent Lepage is initially assumed to be accidental, what does this assumption imply about the collective mindset of the residents of Three Pines? Contrast this widespread belief with Gamache’s initial reaction and explain the reasons underlying his differing opinion.

Gamache is particularly terrified of John Fleming because he knows the full extent of the gruesome crimes that Fleming committed. Is it fair that Gamache has to carry this horrible knowledge? Why does Gamache keep this information a secret, and why does he eventually decide to disclose the gruesome details?

Using at least three different characters, examine the status of Three Pines as a haven from the evils of the world. How does the murder mystery destroy this illusion? Use specific examples from the text to support your interpretation.

Various characters criticize Gamache for retiring and choosing a secluded life in Three Pines. How does Gamache respond to these criticisms? Does he feel conflicted about retiring from the police force? What are some of the possible future plans that Gamache considers, and why do those appeal to him?

Gamache is eventually pushed to consider a huge risk: releasing Fleming from prison in exchange for information about the plans. Why does Gamache consider this option, and how does he justify this decision?

Some individuals are primarily concerned with solving the murders, while others are focused on ensuring that the supergun does not fall into the hands of criminals. What arguments do both sides make to justify their priorities, and why are these priorities portrayed in opposition to one another?

Ruth has been haunted for decades by the shameful secret that she facilitated the connection between John Fleming and Al Lepage. Why did she make this choice, and why did she feel the need to conceal it?

Throughout the novel, Gamache has no formal role of authority in the police force. What limitations does his lack of status impose on his investigation? How does he circumvent these limitations, and why is he still able to play a pivotal role in solving the case? What kind of leadership does Gamache exemplify throughout the novel?