46 pages • 1 hour read
Content Warning: This section of the guide describes depictions of antisemitic discrimination, violence, and genocide in the context of World War II, which feature in the source text.
Family is a complex theme in Then. For Felix, protecting his chosen family is his primary motivation. For Zelda, however, it is a more deeply nuanced subject. Both children have lost their families of origin to the Holocaust and the war; even their surrogate family—Barney and the orphans from Once—have been sent to a death camp. Until they meet and accept Genia as their new caretaker, the two children see each other as the only remaining family they have left. While this bond makes them vulnerable, it also makes them strong as they strike out into the world together, looking for a new source of safety.
Zelda’s character arc is based on her struggle to come to terms with her parents’ status as Nazis. Recapping a discovery that occurred in Once, Felix explains:
Her mum and dad were Nazis before the Polish resistance killed them […] When I think about my mum and dad being dead, at least I know they were Jewish and innocent. Poor Zelda has to think about her parents being part of a gang of brutal murderers (11).
Unfortunately, Zelda is far too young to properly grapple with her parents’ beliefs. She struggles with the grief over their deaths and with the knowledge that they aligned themselves with “brutal murderers.” She knows firsthand what the Nazis have done and what they would do to Felix and Genia if they caught them. Consequently, Zelda rejects her parents and even pretends to be Jewish in order to be more like Felix, her new family member.
In a continuation of the family theme, Zelda makes Felix promise to be with her forever. Because of everything he has been through, Felix thinks, “I remember how Mum and Dad promised to come back one day and they never did. But I know they wanted to. That’s the important thing with a promise. You must want to keep it” (12). This reflection is a harshly mature thought for a 10-year-old and further emphasizes the trauma he has known, but Felix does try his best to keep the promise. After the incident in which an SS soldier nearly hits Zelda with his rifle and hits Felix instead, the boy is forced to confront the fact that his very presence endangers Zelda and Genia. His parents’ example taught him that sometimes it is necessary to leave in order to protect loved ones from danger.
Regarding Once, Morris Gleitzman explains that one of his goals for writing the series was to provide a voice for the innumerable children who had their stories stolen by the Holocaust. Thus, Felix’s adventures in Then continue to serve as a proxy for those children whose stories were never told. Felix’s parents owned a bookstore, so Felix grew up surrounded by literature and storytelling. Richmal Crompton, a British author, is famous for her William and Violet stories, and she is Felix’s favorite author because of her ability to depict the good in people and the strong family ties of her protagonists. In Then, Felix continues his unusual quirk of “praying” to Richmal Crompton for good outcomes in bad situations. This foible is used to portray the profound therapeutic value of storytelling in the midst of real-life tragedy. Indeed, psychologists and therapists often use it as a tool to provide relief for the fragmentation of traumatized people in order to heal their inability to recognize a coherent story in their own lives. It is a proven method for helping those who suffer from trauma and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). This aspect of storytelling is clearly demonstrated when Genia urges Dov to draw the story of what happened to him and his family instead of telling it in words.
Felix initially uses his storytelling skills to shield and distract Zelda from the harsh world around them. For example, as they flee from the train, he tells Zelda stories about food and a friendly cook to help her forget about her injured and hurting feet. Even Genia recognizes Felix’s affinity for storytelling and the comforts it can bring. On the first night Felix and Zelda stay with her, Genia asks, “Can you tell another one? […] About a Polish man who’s forced to go to Germany to work for the Nazis and who comes home safely?” (34). Though she does not elaborate, Felix realizes that she is missing her husband, Gabriek. Genia does not often reveal her inner feelings, possibly so that Felix will not worry about her, but she is suffering as well. At this point, she does not know if Gabriek is alive or dead, and Felix’s story comforts her.
By the end of the novel, storytelling becomes Felix’s main motive for living on, for he knows it is his responsibility to remember those whose stories were cut short. Anger and grief temporarily warps Felix’s character beyond recognition; the gentle boy who could not even kill a rabbit nearly commits to a suicide bombing that would have killed dozens of his enemies. Rather than giving into his rage and seeking revenge, however, Felix ultimately recognizes that he is now the only keeper of Zelda’s life story. All other people who knew her are now gone. Prior to his plan to run away, Felix wrote an account of “[t]he story of Zelda and Genia and their loving hearts” and he goes on to say, “It’s the most important story I’ve ever written, and it’s very easy to write because it’s already come true” (102). This story is the written testimony of Zelda and Genia’s lives: an essential tool for Felix to preserve their memories. By living on and remembering them, Felix can show people what Zelda was like; he can affirm her existence by being the best person he can be and using her story as an example against violence, hatred, and cruelty.
Felix is primarily characterized by hope, belief in humanity, and altruism; even if he is naïve, it is due to his essentially good nature. However, the trauma he suffers through enduring loss after loss and bearing witness to endless Nazi atrocities finally begins to erode his willingness to forgive. Little by little, thoughts of revenge begin to pop up throughout his narrative. After being shot at several times by Nazi soldier and finding the mass grave of dead Jewish orphans, Felix’s thoughts turn uncharacteristically bitter and rageful:
I want to jump out and find a sharp stick and creep up on those Nazis and stab them hundreds of times until their guts are hanging out and they beg for mercy and promise never to shoot people ever again. But I wouldn’t show them mercy, I’d keep stabbing them and stabbing them […] (10).
While this imagery is jarring, especially in the mind of one so young, it is reflective of the world that Felix has been forced to endure. He has seen more death and destruction and has lost more than any 10-year-old ever should, and his normally kind nature struggles to cope with it.
When the Nazis execute Zelda, Genia, and Mr. Krol, Felix has nothing left to lose. He teams up with Dov to exact revenge against the Nazis. Revenge is Dov’s main motivation as a character. Wary of the world, he is quick to violence in self-defense. Felix begins to use similar language as Dov as he describes their infiltration of the former orphanage:
The big house ahead of us is all lit up. I can see guards at the gates. Soldiers and officers strutting around inside. All with guns. All trained to fight. And Hitler Youth vermin who say they’ll protect innocent kids but don’t. I should be scared, but I’m not (109).
Dov previously refers to the Nazis as “vermin” and “scum,” and now Felix uses “vermin” specifically to refer to Amon, who failed to protect Zelda. This is also the same rhetoric the Nazis and Nazi sympathizers (like Cyryl) use toward Jewish people, suggesting that hatred begets hatred and culminates in a cycle of violence. Unlike Dov, Felix ultimately decides to back out of this cycle before it is too late. Dov’s death therefore suggests that seeking revenge, no matter how justified it may be, is ultimately self-destructive. When Amon gives Felix the locket that Zelda intended for him, the gift reminds Felix of what Zelda would think if he were to follow through with his plan to bomb the Nazi headquarters. This moment of remembrance saves his life, and so he vows to become a better person in order to keep Zelda’s memory alive.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Morris Gleitzman
Action & Adventure
View Collection
Art
View Collection
Coping with Death
View Collection
Family
View Collection
Good & Evil
View Collection
International Holocaust Remembrance Day
View Collection
Juvenile Literature
View Collection
Memorial Day Reads
View Collection
Military Reads
View Collection
Popular Study Guides
View Collection
Revenge
View Collection
Safety & Danger
View Collection
Sexual Harassment & Violence
View Collection
World War II
View Collection